parker.mov / editologica

concept production-context ◆ established

"Try Every Idea" Philosophy

n editorial approach, articulated by editor Eddie Hamilton, that mandates physically trying any suggested change, no matter how small or unlikely. The core principle is that it is often faster to execute an idea and see if it contains a 'spark of genius' than it is to debate its theoretical merits, ensuring no potential improvement is left unexplored. This philosophy specifically encourages attempting edits that seem unconventional or even 'wrong' on paper. The core belief is that the true effect of a cut can only be judged once it is physically executed and viewed, as surprising and effective results can emerge from counter-intuitive choices.

notes

Vashi Nedomansky frames this as 'Attempt Edits That Shouldn't Work.' It's a great way to think about it. You have to be willing to break your own rules to find something new. The undo button is your best friend.

criteria

  • Embrace a 'childlike' creativity, where ideas are tested without the immediate judgment of whether they are 'good' or 'correct'.

visual examples

  • Arrival (2016) — Editor Joe Walker initially dismissed a suggestion from director Denis Villeneuve as 'the stupidest idea,' but by exploring it, they discovered a crucial creative breakthrough for the film.

related · 7